Hi Dr. Dan. It is interesting topic! And I hope you will answer my few questions.
1) What is the mechanics of using antidepressants? Ye, I know that they regulate serotonin level and level of other neurotransmitters. But I mean therapeutic effect. What happens when person stops using antidepressants? Her chemical balance just states to normal after that? How? These are just pills which provide temporary effect. How they can work after you stop using them? I guess it is just a painkiller. People should use it all of his life in order not to feel anxiety? Are there some scientific evidence that people get better after quitting antidepressants than they were before starting them?
I don't really want to argue with you. I need that information for my working activity.=)
As a person who overcame panic disorder I can't just agree with everything you said and can't just pass by. But it is not necessary that you answer my further questions. It's good that you try to help people, and I value it. Better to channel your energy on helping people on this forum than arguing with me or someone else. But if you have time and will after answering to people who have trouble, you can take into account following:
2) You mentioned that not everyone is effected by CBT therapy for example. But it attempts to change the reaction towards your panic and fear. If we change reaction to it, know how to relax ourself, we will benefit. Everyone will benefit, no matter what kind of person is it. So it is just a matter of time and patience.
3) Requirements for using willpower and patience in treatment are actually not disadvantages. These qualities are essential for long-term success in fighting anxiety. And searching for magic pill, quick solutions are the real disadvantages. If a person doesn't want to devote some time and work towards getting rid of anxiety, he will be completely helpless in front of new stress, new panic attacks. Again and again he will look for new pills.
4) You said that therapy don't work for everyone. But do antidepressants? I know a lot of people who went from one medicines to other, and it didn't help. They tried different pills but no help. Some of them got just addictions and unpleasant side effects (like troubles with libido and erection, that boosted their anxiety even more!)

